7 years ago, back in 23 December 2005, the MOE released a pekeliling to schools stating that students are allowed to bring handphones to school. But then in less than one month, on 20 January 2006, MOE decided to
Of course back then in 2006, there were huge debate between the pros and cons of bringing handphones to school. Most adults (parents and educators) had strong opinions on this issue and also some students (I read a news where head prefects were interviewed and shared their opinion) had their say. Back then social media wasn't that popular in Malaysia so no one was vocal about the issue I guess. And no one was demonstrating :P
The Personal Story
My personal experience was this. I wanted to bring my handphone to school once when I was form 3, 4 or 5, couldn't remember clearly. I need the handphone to call my mum to fetch me home because I was going somewhere else first. I knew the consequences of bringing of the forbidden item to school - say goodbye to your phone because it'll be confiscated and only can be retrieved at the end of the year. (Ya school sucks because even if your parents comes to school asking to claim the phone back, the school would ask you to collect it during December holidays -_-).
So, naive as I am, I went up to a teacher, asked her if she could keep the phone for me first and I will get the phone from her after school. I have no intentions to use the phone during school, see? But no, the teacher says that she don't want to bear any responsibility and she warns me if I bring it to school, she will confiscate it. -_-; Don't know how I should response. Sigh. It's a lose-lose situation for me back then. I wanted to be honest, I really need the phone but the teacher doesn't want to "help" me. So what option do I have? Break the rules then.
The For Argument
1. Technological Advancement - There are countries that allow students to bring phones to school many years ago. We're lagging behind. It's good to motivate and encourage innovation through phones. It's a basic need to have a phone nowadays.
2. Safety - Parents/Children need to contact each other easily
3. Schools are there to educate - A good opportunity to educate discipline in students.
4. Cost and long-term benefit for Mama nature - Introduce e-books. Save papers.
5. Gen Y are tech savvy - Since Gen Y peeps are tech savvy, it's good to capitalize on their strengths.
6. Maturity issues - If this is about maturity (in handling one's own gadget and how they use it), adults shouldn't be allowed to bring their gadgets to workplace too because they also Facebook/Call/Text/Do other stuff
The Against Argument
1. Distractions - Games, Texting, INTERNET (with the Internet you can practically do everything now)
2. Peer Pressure - Less privileged students will feel the pressure when they see all their peers surrounding them have a (smart)phone.
3. More Work For Teachers (Mostly this is from a teacher's POV) - Teachers would now have more responsibility to look after students' gadgets and monitor their behavior (ie. don't let them break the rules/guidelines)
4. Maturity issues - Students are not matured enough to have good self-control and would abuse the gadgets to other stuffs that are not school-related when in school.
5. Safety - Bullying, Stealing, Robbery, Kidnapping?
6. More Highschool Drama - Video, Pictures, Cyberbullying.. *think Gossip Girl :P
My personal opinion
Sure, a lot of people are concerned about how handphones would create a lot of problems, I agree. Social problems from mobile usage are already on the rise. I can imagine a 14 year old girl tweeting non-stop the whole day about everything they see in school, on the way home and at home. (I've seen soooo many teenagers, girls especially, tweeting away like 1k tweet a day. That's mad -_-)
Unless students are very confident in themselves that they have super good self-control, I suggest that they leave the phone at home unless it is necessary for them to bring the phone. Because of the mobile media revolution, phones have become a greater distraction. And with the MOE saying that they would provide free wifi, there would be more problems. Students can easily access Facebook and Twitter which is already known for how addictive they could be, and then Whatsapp comes into the picture. Students can text away without even thinking because it's free! Sigh, even I find it hard sometimes to concentrate in class because I have a smartphone. *Bish.
Stealing of phones are just secondary issues to me because I think if the teachers and school authorities are willing to "help" students keep this phones safely, there shouldn't be any problem. Like provide students with lockers or just put them inside staff room or something. I'm sure things will work out if there is proper management and security. You don't see phones getting stolen easily in colleges unless you leave them lying around.
BUT, students might be easy victims to robbery or snatch thefts if not careful because now everyone knows students can bring a phone and that most probably students will. And of course, bullying come into the picture.
I know the reason that students are allowed to bring handphones is because we're already considered backdated and we're lagging behind. But I don't see how bringing handphones or any IT gadgets would effectively help our nation to progress further. Maybe it's because I cannot comprehend it yet due to lack of exposure? In defense, I would like to justify this matter :P MOE claims that all if not most schools are already equipped with computing facilities.. but are students taught how to use it properly? Nopes. I didn't learn to use Excel, Words or Powerpoint in school (oh, I'm talking about national schools here btw). In fact, I've never used any computer in school for my entire high school life.
Unless handphones or the gadgets are really put into good use, I doubt how it would really help us to be better all. That being said, using gadgets to learn and do revision.. Has anyone done the research to prove its effectiveness? Because I think if I were to use iPad to read something, I would toggle away when a Facebook notification pops out. I'm just being realistic.
There is no doubt that new rules and guidelines would be introduced to ensure that students will not retaliate and abuse the privilege to bring the phones to school. But what I am afraid is how rules would turn out to be, in the name of "discipline". I have listed some of the most ridiculous rules introduced to students by schools because they want students to be more discipline. You can read about it (here) and (here).
Actually, I kinda see more cons to pros in this whole issue. But that's just me. May be I cannot accept such change. I think if this implementation ought to take place next year, proper measures must be taken in order to reduce the possibilities that students will get distracted, bullying etc NOW. Let me know what you think.
P/S: Surprise, surprise: according to StarEducate editor, it was found out most teachers AND STUDENTS are against phones in school whereas parents love it (source: link) Ain't that surprising? :P